Carse & Waterman · Winter campaign 2026/27

This is a potato.

Every business starts as a potato. Some stay one.

In January, a beautiful box lands on 60 carefully chosen desks. Inside is a potato and a QR code. The film it opens explains why, and starts a year-long story about what C&W does: turning plain products into things people understand, remember and act on.

Tease December Drop w/c 11 January 2027 Story all of 2027
The Potato Collection box: a charcoal gift box with a gold-foil sleeve, open to show a single potato on an orange wool layer, with 'What's with the potato?' and a QR code inside the lid
3D render · The Potato Collection
DRAFT 3 · AFTER THE 26 OCTOBER MEETING

What we settled. What's still open.

Daniel, Gary and Pete went through the plan. The concept held up. Each open question now has options and a recommendation in its own chapter, marked with a dashed blue box.

Settled

  • 60 boxes, with marketing directors and agencies up front. One agency can bring work from many brands.
  • The box, rendered as "The Potato Collection": charcoal and gold, orange wool, a bare potato.
  • One QR code and one personalised page per recipient.
  • Vault photos, clue posts and a Christmas card with a clue.
  • The Spud Squad: problem statements with solutions attached.
  • Cost-of-the-problem calculator, not an animation price calculator.
  • Relationship marketing, not a hard sell.

Still open

CH 01

Same potato. Different story.

Nobody orders a plain potato. They order chips, a jacket, a roastie. The potato never changed; the presentation did. That's the whole campaign, and it's what we do for a living. Tap through a potato's career.

CH 01 · RAW

Just a potato.

Good idea. Lots of hard work. Loads of potential. From the outside, it looks exactly like every other potato in the sack.

In business terms

A product with no story. People walk past it, not because it's bad, but because nothing tells them why it matters.

Attentionthe box× Desirethe film + story× Conversionthe Spud Check

One message all year: most business problems are communication problems. The box earns attention the Duolingo way, the film and characters build desire the Sutherland way, and the offer converts the Hormozi way. Any part at zero and the whole sum is zero.

CH 02

Keep the name. Soften the landing.

"Don't Be a Spud" is short, British and repeatable. On its own, "spud" can also mean "idiot", which is a strange thing to post to a prospect. Each line below has one job.

Every business starts as a potato. Some stay one.
The campaign line

Works for a start-up and a 40-year-old firm alike. A gentle challenge, not a jab. (Updated after the meeting, see below.)

Don't Be a Spud
Campaign + hashtag

Punchy and shareable. Always shown near the line above.

So, is your business a spud?
The film's last line

Pete's idea. Asked only after 90 seconds of context, so the metaphor has landed. On the landing page it becomes "So, is KMF a spud?"

The Potato Principle
Thought leadership

The talk, the monthly article, the thing Daniel and Gary own on stage.

What's with the potato?
Inside the lid only

From the box render. Says out loud what they're thinking, then points to the QR code.

1

One potato joke per piece, maximum. The idea is funny on its own. Stack the puns and it turns into a gimmick, and that's not how we talk.

OPEN QUESTION · RAISED BY GARY

Does "every business starts as a potato" work for a 40-year-old metal firm?

Gareth at KMF isn't starting out. Read literally, the line doesn't fit him. The room's answer was that established firms are potatoes too if nothing sets them apart. Spud is 20th-century presentation; the question is what the 21st-century version looks like.

Option A · keep it

Every business starts as a potato.

Simple and warm, but it speaks to start-ups and leaves established firms out.

Option B · recommended

Every business starts as a potato. Some stay one.

Four extra words make it fit everyone. KMF started plain decades ago; the question is whether it stayed that way. It's a gentle challenge, not an insult.

Option C · a question

Is your business a spud?

Direct and memorable. On its own, though, people may not get the metaphor. It works best as the ending, after the film has explained it.

Option D · define it

spud /spʌd/ noun

"A perfectly good business that looks, sounds and feels exactly like everyone else's." A dictionary definition fixes the metaphor problem before anyone has to guess. Put it on the card in the box and the landing page.

Recommendation: use all three in their places. B as the campaign line, D on the card and the landing page so nobody's left guessing, and C as the film's final line and the landing page question ("So, is KMF a spud?"). Never call a named company a spud in public, even in jest.

CH 03

Sixty desks. Chosen properly.

Sixty boxes means every one can be personal. Each goes to someone who could sign off a £10k project, introduce us to someone who can, or help the story travel. Small enough that Daniel and Gary can know every name on the list.

Tier A · Hot
15 boxes
  • Past clients, open proposals, warm leads, agency partners
  • Potato stamped with their company name
  • Personalised film end card
  • A handwritten note from Daniel or Gary
Tier B · Target
35 boxes
  • Named decision-makers we'd love to work with
  • Standard box, unique QR code
  • A personal hello once it lands
Tier C · Friends
10 boxes
  • Chambers members, university partners, councils, charities, local press, Animation UK
  • They amplify. They don't have to buy.
First: Marketing agencies, especially large ones First: Marketing directors Manufacturing & engineering Health & safety leads Universities & research
OPEN QUESTION · FROM PETE'S POINT

Do agencies need their own angle?

Pete's case: one agency relationship brings work from many brands, and big agencies move fast on anything new because their clients always want something new. But an agency isn't really the potato. Their clients are.

Option A

Same box, same page

Simplest. The film still makes them smile, but it asks the wrong question of them.

Option B · recommended

Same box, an agency page

A third landing-page version: "Your clients have potatoes too." Leads with the white-label offer (your agency's animation studio, under your name) and turns the Spud Check into a look at one of their live briefs.

Option C

An agency kit

Their box includes a couple of spare potatoes to pass on to their own clients, with a co-branded card. Fun, but it costs more and needs their sign-off.

Recommendation: B. Make around 10 of the 35 Tier B boxes large agencies, and give them their own page. The landing-page template can take a third version with a few lines of new copy.

CH 04 · LATE NOV TO CHRISTMAS

Tease the box. Never the potato.

Four light touches. We never show the inside and we never say the word. The surprise is the whole value, so we don't spend it early. We work in a bank, so the boxes get guarded like it's a heist.

W/C 23 NOV · EMAIL
A small New Year gift is heading your way. It's not a calendar.The address check, reworked after the meeting (see below). A free, harmless first touch.
EARLY DEC · THE VAULT
Something's in the vault.Stacked boxes in the basement vault, team on guard, totally deadpan. A gold-painted "golden spud" can star in the shoot without giving the game away.
DEC · MON / WED / FRI
Weighs about 250g. Older than the printing press.One photo, one dry clue. Invite guesses. Never confirm one.
~18 DEC · LAST POST
It's not a sprout.Our Christmas card line. Then silence until it lands.
No countdown site, ads or press release. They all spend the surprise before the box does.
No full box reveal. Crop it, light it moodily, show corners.
End every clue with an invitation: "A few are going out in January. Want one? Message us." The tease becomes lead capture.
OPEN QUESTION · PETE PLAYED DEVIL'S ADVOCATE

Do we ask for an address, and what if nobody replies?

A non-reply might mean "not interested", or just "busy". People don't know what's coming, so asking them to opt in to a mystery is a big ask. Daniel's reason for keeping it: home workers, and a check the potato reaches the right person.

Option A · ask

"Where should it go?"

Needs a reply. Lots of people won't send one, and then you're stuck.

Option B · tell · recommended

"Here's where it's going"

"A small New Year gift is heading your way in January. We've got it going to your office at [address]. If you'd rather it went somewhere else, just reply. Otherwise, no need to do a thing."

No reply is fine: it goes to the office. Pete's New Year framing makes it feel normal, and it's still a free first touch.

Option C · skip it

Office addresses only

Check addresses through LinkedIn or a quick call to reception. Keeps the surprise total, but loses the first touch.

Recommendation: B for Tiers A and B. Tier C (friends and partners) can skip it, since you know where they are.

CH 05 · W/C 11 JANUARY 2027

A posh box. A plain potato.

Boxes land Tuesday to Thursday of the second week back, when inboxes have settled and people are planning the year. The contrast is the joke, so the box has to look genuinely expensive.

The Potato Collection: the open box with a potato on an orange wool layer, the closed box in its gold-foil sleeve, and a close-up of the wool on the corrugated cardboard cradle
3D render of the box. A cardboard box and sleeve, with an orange wool layer over a cardboard cradle: cost-efficient, environmentally friendly, and it looks high end.

The sleeve

"The Potato Collection. Made in Stoke-on-Trent." Gold foil on matte charcoal, with fields and bottle kilns along the bottom. It looks like artisan chocolate or a watch, which is the point.

Inside the lid

"What's with the potato?" and a QR code: "Scan to uncover the story." The only explanation, and the only way out of the confusion.

Orange wool on a cardboard cradle

Protects the potato in the post and lets it breathe, which suits a seed potato. Natural and recyclable materials, and the brand orange does the "this is special" work.

One seed potato, bare

Looks like any potato, but it can be planted in March. No foil or wrapping: a bare potato on a wool bed is the joke.

Envelope and grow card

Googly eyes, a name tag and "Plant it in March. Some potatoes grow." They're not in the render yet. They could sit under the wool layer or inside the sleeve, so the potato still appears alone.

Tier A extras

The potato hand-stamped with their company name in food-safe ink, their name on the film's end card, and Pete's potato-biography card.

THREE THINGS TO CHECK WITH THE SUPPLIER

The render works. These details decide whether it survives the post.

Unique QR codes

The lid prints in one run, so its code can't change per box. Leave a space in the lid design and add each recipient's code as a gold sticker when you pack.

Who it's from

The gift box carries no C&W name, which keeps the mystery. Put Carse & Waterman on the outer posting box or label so mailrooms don't bin it.

£500 for 60

That's about £8.30 a box, including the sleeve, foil and wool. That may be tight for short-run foil printing, so get quotes before locking the budget.

Open it

It's a potato. Confusion. A photo to a colleague: "what is this?"

Scan it

"What's with the potato?" The lid gives exactly one way out of the confusion.

Watch it

The film explains the potato, and tells them to open the envelope.

Post it

Eyes on, potato named, photo posted with #DontBeASpud. The campaign spreads itself.

Every box gets its own QR code.

Each one opens a personal page (carseandwaterman.com/spud/acme) with the film and a Book your Spud Check button. We'll know who's watched, so we know who to say a proper hello to, and who might just need a gentle reminder the film exists. One shared code would tell us nothing.

CH 06 · THE FILM · 75–90 SECONDS

Every business starts as a potato.

The film is the product demo. If it makes someone feel something about a potato, they'll believe we can do it for their business. It apologises, explains, shows off, and asks for one thing.

00:00–00:08

Hello. You've just been sent a potato. Sorry about that. Stick with us. It's a good potato.

The real potato on the real box, filmed plainly.

00:08–00:20

Every business starts as a potato. A good idea, lots of hard work. And from the outside, it looks exactly like every other potato.

Stop-motion potato lost in a crowd of identical ones.

00:20–00:40

But a potato can be a lot of things. Chips. Dinner. Art. A clock. Give it a face, and suddenly it's somebody. Same potato. Different story.

Fast montage: one potato, five lives.

00:40–00:55

The difference was never the potato. It's how you show it, how you explain it, and whether anyone feels a thing. Nobody stops scrolling for a plain potato.

Split screen: plain potato ignored, transformed potato mobbed.

00:55–01:10

We're Carse & Waterman. For 17 years we've turned potatoes into things people remember, for the BBC, the NHS, the UN and businesses just down the road. Most business problems are communication problems. That's what we fix.

Flashes of real client work, then The Bank.

01:10–01:30

So, open the envelope. Give your potato a face and a name, and post it. Plant it in March. And if you want to know what yours could be, book a Spud Check.

Envelope opens, eyes go on. The iMe mark closes the film.

What the film proves

The film is the pitch. In 90 seconds it does the three things we promise every client, to the person watching it.

UnderstandA baffling object becomes completely clear in under a minute.
RememberThey'll never look at a potato the same way again.
ActEyes on, name it, post it. One small, easy next step.
OPEN QUESTION · GARY VS DANIEL, PETE IN THE MIDDLE

Who tells the story: a narrator, or the potato?

The storyboard above is narrated. Gary felt it reads like an explainer about a potato, and wants the potato to tell its own story, with a family of potato jokes. Daniel worried that loses the point (the potato is meant to be plain) and that drier corporate targets won't warm to a cartoon.

Option A · narrator

As storyboarded above

Clear and corporate-safe. Less charm, and it explains rather than makes you feel.

Option B · the potato speaks · recommended

Gary's version, built so the jokes do the explaining

The trick: his family members are the transformations. They all became something; he's the one who stayed plain. So the jokes carry the lesson, and Daniel's point about plainness becomes the whole story.

Option C · hybrid

Narrator plus a silent potato

Our voice tells the story; the potato reacts with its eyes and timing. Personality without a talking cartoon. A good fallback for drier audiences.

Option D · Pete's split

Jokes on a card, business in the film

A short "potato biography" card in the box carries the family gags; the film stays businesslike.

Option B · first-draft script, about 90 seconds

"Hi. I'm a potato. You've probably noticed.
I come from a very successful family. Dad's in the spud gun business. Mum went into mash. Corporate burnout, but she's doing well. My brother works at McDonald's. My cousin went to America and came back as a crisp. Calls himself a chip now.
Me? Same soil. Same start. Nothing wrong with me. Nobody's ever picked me off the shelf, though.
Turns out the difference was never the potato. It's how you're shown, how you're explained, and whether anyone feels a thing when they see you.
That's what the people who sent me do. Carse & Waterman have spent 17 years turning plain into memorable, for the BBC, the NHS, the UN and businesses just down the road.
So, give me some eyes. Give me a name. Plant me in March and we'll see what I become.
And while you're at it… is your business a spud?"

Recommendation: B. It's funnier, it's more lovable, and it still makes the business point in plain words in the second half, which is what the drier audiences need. The family gags are the one place the "one joke per piece" rule bends, because the gags are the explanation. Use D as well for Tier A: the biography card is a lovely extra in the box.

Three questions to ask your potato

Printed under the film on every landing page. The thing people keep after the laugh.

1

What does your potato look like to a stranger?

Not to you. To someone with three seconds and no context.

2

What's the one thing it should be known for?

If you can't say it in a sentence, nobody else can either.

3

Does anyone feel anything when they see it?

People don't remember information. They remember how something made them feel.

CH 07 · 2027

Receive it. Plant it. Harvest it. Serve it.

Because it's a seed potato, the year writes itself. Four chapters, one message, each told through a different stage of the potato's life, with one real-world moment in each.

JAN – MAR

Every business starts as a potato

The drop, the film, people naming and posting their spuds. Spud Check afternoons at The Bank, with tea and oatcakes.

Lesson: your product isn't the problem. How it's explained might be.

APR – JUN

Plant it

A "time to plant" postcard in mid-March. The Spud Squad launches. A potato printing workshop with Framescape, a nod to Stoke's printed pottery. International Day of Potato content on Fri 28 May.

Lesson: good communication gets planted early. Onboarding, training, first impressions.

JUL – SEP

Harvest

Recipients share what grew. A jacket potato van outside The Bank: free jackets for local businesses, a Chambers "Jacket & Chat", and cardboard Spud Squad cut-outs for photos. In September, the Potato Principle talk.

Lesson: show the results. What did better comms actually return?

OCT – DEC

Serve it up

Bonfire Night jackets on Fri 5 Nov. The Spud Awards for the best transformations of the year. A Christmas roastie finale that hands the audience to the 2028 campaign.

Lesson: presentation is everything.

CH 08 · RECURRING CHARACTERS

Meet the Spud Squad.

Twelve potatoes, each one a communication problem our clients actually have: in sales, in factories, in training rooms, in lecture halls and in communities. Every one is something we fix, so every appearance is quietly a pitch. Recipients will recognise their own business in at least one of them.

The Mumbler

Brilliant at the job. Can't explain it to anyone outside the room.

→ Explainer films that simplify

The Everything Spud

Says fourteen things at once, so nobody remembers one.

→ Message strategy: one thing, done well

The Invisible Spud

Great product. Nobody's ever heard of it.

→ Brand films and social that earn attention

The Beige Spud

Looks identical to every competitor on the shelf.

→ Identity, character and mascot work

The Shouty Spud

All sales, no story. "BUY NOW" on every single post.

→ Storytelling that makes people care first

The Unread Spud

The safety policy everyone signs and nobody reads.

→ H&S animation, LMS and on-site mascots

The Tangled Spud

A product or process so complex that nobody can picture how it works.

→ Product breakdowns, exploded views, process films

The Lost Spud

New starters who spend their first month wondering what's going on.

→ Onboarding and induction films

The Snoozing Spud

Training and lectures that send the room to sleep by slide four.

→ Learning content for teams, schools and universities

The Whisper Spud

The message changes every time it's passed down the company.

→ Internal comms that say it once, clearly, to everyone

The Lonely Spud

Puts on the event, launches the programme, and nobody comes.

→ Engagement tools, workshops and event promotion

The Pitching Spud

A brilliant idea that keeps losing the tender, the funding bid or the investor.

→ Pitch, bid and investor films

A story, not a schedule

A fixed 12-posts-a-month grid gets predictable fast. Instead, the year runs like a series: a few recurring formats people look forward to, some they take part in, and a few that only happen when there's a reason. A post goes out when it has something to say. Roughly two a week, never filler.

EVERY OTHER WEEK

The Spud Squad: the series

A running workplace comedy, not one-off skits. The Squad share an office, each chapter has its own storyline, and episodes end on something worth coming back for. When the Lost Spud starts a new job in spring, the whole Squad has to explain the place to them.

Watch
MONTHLY

Spud Surgery

People send in a real communication problem. We sketch how we'd fix it in 60 seconds. Genuinely useful, and the start of a lot of good conversations.

Take part
LAUNCH ONCE, RUNS ALL YEAR

Which spud is your business?

A six-question quiz on the website. Your answer is one of the twelve Squad characters, with a shareable result card and a tip for fixing it.

Take part
MONTHLY CHECK-IN

The window spud

Our own potato, planted in a pot in The Bank's front window, filmed as a time-lapse all year. Locals can watch it grow from the street.

Watch
WHEN IT HAPPENS

Your spuds

Recipients' named, planted and harvested potatoes, shared and celebrated as they arrive. Never forced onto a schedule.

Celebrate
WHEN IT HAPPENS

Hot potato

When a communication story is in the news, the Squad has a kind, funny take on what went wrong and what would have helped.

React
MONTHLY

The Potato Principle

A short article from Daniel or Gary: one communication lesson, told plainly.

Read
AT EVENTS

Cardboard Squad

Life-size cut-outs of the characters at the Spud Van, Spud Check afternoons and talks. People take the photos; we share them.

Take part
CH 09 · THE LANDING PAGE

Their name is the first thing they see.

Pete's point: the landing page is where the campaign turns into conversations, and the more personal it feels, the more people engage. But don't rewrite every line for every person. Be clever about what changes.

HELLO AGAIN, LISA. Yes, Lisa. It's a potato.
Is there a spud somewhere in Alpha? Your free 2027 Spud Check → Alpha isn't a spud. But you probably know one.
HELLO, GARETH. Yes. That's a potato.
So, is KMF a spud? Book a Spud Check → We're Carse & Waterman. Who sent you a potato.

One page, sixty people

Each QR code points to the same page with a short code on the end, like carseandwaterman.com/spud?k=kmf. The code looks up the name and company and fills them in. No code shows a friendly default. Same structure for everyone; the words around it change by relationship.

Existing client · Lisa, Alpha
New prospect · Gareth, KMF
Greeting
"Hello again, Lisa." Thanks for working together.
"Hello, Gareth." Sorry for the strange parcel.
Spud definition
"Alpha? Definitely not a spud."
"Great product, shame about the spud."
Spud finder
"Is there a spud somewhere in Alpha?" A new product, a process, a corner that's still plain.
"So, is KMF a spud?" With a gentle sector guess: The Tangled Spud.
Spud Check
A 2027 catch-up about what's next, not a review of past work.
A first look at one thing KMF finds hard to get across.
Last section
"Pass the potato": tell us who you know, and we'll send them a box and say it was your idea.
Who we are: 17 years, the client list, the old bank in Stoke.
The spud finderPete's idea. Type a problem in a few words, or pick one. It tells you which of the 12 Squad characters you are and what we'd do, then fills in the Spud Check form for you.
No hard sell"If now's not the right time, the potato's still yours." The page invites; it never chases.
Built to moveOne HTML page with a recipient list at the top. Ready to drop into a Squarespace code block.
CH 10 · TURNING SPUDS INTO SALES

The film does the selling.

If the film lands, people will want to talk. If it doesn't, no amount of chasing would fix that, and chasing isn't who we are. So the job after the drop is to make it easy to say hello, and to keep being good company until they're ready. For some that's January. For others it's next autumn.

60
Boxes delivered
42
Scanned 70%
34
Watched to the end 80% of scanners
15
Posted their potato
10
Real conversations during 2027
5
Proposals
2–3
Projects won at ~£10k + VAT

Proposed targets to agree with Gary. Scan rates are higher than a cold mailer because every box is chosen and personal. Bar widths are to scale.

Spud Check

30 minutes + a one-page Potato Report

Free

Message Session

Half a day to nail the one message. For people not ready to commission yet.

Small, paid

The Transformation

The film that solves their communication problem, plus the pieces to use it everywhere. This is the sell.

~£10k + VAT

Your own potato

We design a confusing mailer and film for their business.

Bespoke + VAT
The offer

The Spud Check

A free 30-minute call or studio visit. We look at one thing they're struggling to communicate, and send back a one-page Potato Report within a week:

  1. What your potato looks like to a stranger
  2. The one thing it should be known for
  3. What we'd do about it, with a rough cost and timeline

"If we can't find one thing worth improving, lunch is on us."

Making £10k feel small

Don't sell the film. Sell the cost of the problem. In a Spud Check, ask "what did this communication problem cost you in 2026?" and work it out together. This is the conversation as a concept, with example numbers.

The problem cost about £14,000 in 2026

The Transformation is £10,000 + VAT, once. The problem costs that again every year it isn't fixed.

OPEN QUESTION · GARY'S WATERPROOF TROUSERS

Should we make people feel they got a good deal?

Gary paid £25 for trousers "reduced from £87" and felt clever. Could we say a film "normally costs £50k"? Daniel didn't like it: it risks a race to the bottom, damages perceived value, and anyone who buys on a fake discount isn't the right client. Pete's alternative was to show what the solution saves.

Option A · anchor the price

"Normally £50k"

Works on trousers. Undermines a premium studio, and it isn't true.

Option B · cost of the problem

The calculator above

Honest and simple. The anchor is their own pain, not our price list.

Option C · show the saving · recommended

"Fixing this saves you about £4,000 in year one"

Problem cost minus our price, worked out with them in the Potato Report. They get Gary's "I'm not a sucker" feeling from a real number.

Recommendation: B on the landing page, C in the Potato Report and the proposal. Keep the page simple; show the saving once you know their numbers. No fake anchors, ever.

Paying for it, fairly both ways

We make everything up front, so long payment plans put a small studio at risk if a client folds. These options keep it easy for them and safe for us. Nothing is spread beyond 12 months.

Two halves

50% to start, 50% on sign-off, before final files are handed over.

The simple default for most clients.

Pay as it's made

Four equal stages tied to real milestones: start, script, animatic, final. Each stage is paid before the next begins.

Smaller bites for tighter cash flow.

The year plan

Monthly payments over up to 12 months, about £833 + VAT a month on £10k. The work is planned as a year of pieces and released as it's paid for: script and look first, then the main film, then cutdowns and social pieces through the year.

For clients who need it spread. We're never owed for work they already have.

The rule: we're never more than one stage out of pocket, and final files go out once they're paid for. Fair to them, and it keeps the studio safe.

Staying in touch, not following up

After something this clever, a hard sell would undo it. Every touch across the year gives them something: a laugh, an invitation, something useful. The door stays open, and when they're ready, they know where we are.

WEEK 1

A human hello

A short personal note from Daniel or Gary: "Hope your potato arrived in one piece." No link, no ask.

Gives: a person behind the box
WEEK 2

Celebrate their spud

If they post their potato, we cheer it on publicly. If they haven't watched yet, one friendly line in case the potato's still a mystery, with the film. Then nothing more.

Gives: a moment in the spotlight
FEB

An invitation, not a meeting

Spud Check afternoons at The Bank. Tea, oatcakes, a look round the vault. Come with a problem or just come for the tea.

Gives: a reason to visit
MAR

"Time to plant"

A postcard with planting tips. Pure fun, and a reminder two months after the box.

Gives: a smile on a Tuesday
JUL

Harvest and the Spud Van

An invitation to a free jacket potato and a catch-up outside The Bank.

Gives: lunch
MONTHLY

The Potato Principle

One useful communication lesson a month, for anyone who opted in. Easy to unsubscribe.

Gives: something useful
WHENEVER

They're ready

Maybe January, maybe October. They message us, and the conversation starts from a year of goodwill instead of a cold pitch.

Gives: a studio they already trust
Never "just following up"
No more than one personal message a month
Every touch gives something
A quiet no is fine. They stay on the invite list.

Pete's hotel story is this whole plan: the owner gives every guest the same tour, and on the last day hands them chocolates and a signed family photo, with no sales pitch at all. His family were planning to go back before the plane landed.

OPEN QUESTION · PETE'S LOST SALE

Soft is right. But when do we ask?

Everyone agreed on relationship-first. Pete's caveat: he watched someone lose a sale because they never asked for it, and called that a very British habit. Not pushing and not asking are different things.

Option A · never ask

Wait for them

Safe, and some people will come. Others will drift away while they wait to be invited.

Option B · ask on signals · recommended

Ask clearly, once they show interest

Signals: they book a Spud Check, ask what something costs, ask "how did you do that?", forward the film to a colleague, or reply to a hello. Then one plain question, every time: "Would it help if we put a proposal together?"

Option C · ask on a timer

Nudge after 30 days

Predictable, but it's exactly the follow-up feel you want to avoid.

Recommendation: B. Every Spud Check ends with the proposal question, and the Potato Report ends with a clear next step. The rest of the year stays gifts and invitations.

CH 11 · BUDGET

One project pays for the year.

Planned cash spend for 60 boxes and the year around them. The film and the Squad are digital and made in house, so they're studio time, not cash. Protect them in the schedule like a paying job.

Cash total £2,400 One Transformation at £10,000 + VAT covers it four times over
CH 12 · WHAT COULD GO WRONG

Mostly manageable. One isn't optional.

A great box, then silence

The biggest risk by a distance. Not a hard sell, just a human hello. Block w/c 11 and 18 January in the diary before Christmas so Daniel and Gary can write every note themselves.

The potato rots, sprouts or smells

January cold helps. Firm, dry seed potatoes, packed within 48 hours, posted Monday to Wednesday only. Breathable packing.

"Spud" reads as an insult

Always pair it with "Every business starts as a potato. Some stay one." The definition card does the explaining.

Calling real companies spuds

Fine in a meeting room, risky anywhere else. Several examples raised are current or past clients. Never name a business as a spud in public content, even kindly.

Mailroom suspicion

Clear branding on the outer packaging, and the November email means they're expecting something.

Sending abroad

Keep the drop to Great Britain. Plant-health rules make seed potatoes into Northern Ireland and the EU complicated.

Trademarks

A potato with a face, never a named toy brand. No Mr. Potato Head in the film or copy.

Tracking and data

Mention QR tracking in the privacy notice, add an easy opt-out to every email, and check details with whoever handles data compliance.

Client work eats the film

Give it a schedule and a producer like any paying job.

77DAYS TO DISPATCH
CH 13 · NOW TO THE DROP

Order the boxes by the end of November.

The box is the long-lead item, and Christmas eats two weeks, so the film needs to be in animation by early December.

Lock it in NOV

  • w/c 2 NovNext session with Pete: landing page, box. Settle the six open questions.
  • w/c 2 NovBuild the list: 60 names, agencies and marketing directors first.
  • w/c 9 NovSupplier quotes and a sample made from the render. Draft the potato's script.
  • w/c 16 NovLock the script, start the animatic, load the 60 codes into the landing page.
  • w/c 23 Nov"Heading your way" email. Sign off and order the boxes.

Tease and make DEC

  • Early DecVault shoot at The Bank. Clue posts start Mon/Wed/Fri.
  • DecemberAnimate the film. Design the first Spud Squad characters.
  • Before breakBlock time for w/c 11 and 18 Jan to write the hello notes.
  • ~18 Dec"It's not a sprout." Last post and Christmas card.

The drop JAN

  • w/c 4 JanFinal film and cutdowns. Pages live and tested. Buy seed potatoes. Pack.
  • 11–13 JanDispatch.
  • From 13 JanHello notes go out. Reveal posts go live.
  • End JanFirst numbers review.

Every business starts as a potato.

This could be the most talked-about thing Carse & Waterman has ever put through a letterbox. Really, really looking forward to seeing people's faces when they open it.

Prepared for Daniel Waterman and Gary Carse · 26 October 2026

Carse & Waterman Productions Ltd · The Bank, Stoke-on-Trent · International Day of Potato date from FAO